top of page

Interview w/ Duncan Reviews

By Nick Caceres

Published 04/16/2025

When it comes to a body of work, Instagram may not be a first option for many. I’ve had my fair share of mediocre experiences with trying to write on that platform and no, I won’t be sharing any reviews I published on a currently inactive account back in 2019. However, unlike Nick C, someone who's reviews have found insane success on this platform, along with Rate Your Music, is the one and only Duncan Reviews.

 

Perhaps one of the most prolific reviewers next to Fantano, Duncan has been consistently elevating the style of critique, pumping out a trio of endlessly creative and engaging interviews for around half a decade at this point. It’s difficult to find a music nerd favorite that they haven’t hit, to a point where Duncan’s Instagram profile can itself qualify as a tool for discovery. Along with reviews, Duncan manages to use his time effectively for the occasional interview, researching mythology and literature, writing fiction and cooking up mouth watering dishes as a head chef. 

 

The following interview occurred over email between March 25 and April 14, where we discussed Duncan’s recent undertaking of reviewing the entire Diary of a Wimpy Kid series as well as recent music, past reviews, Duncan’s own interviews and future goals for the content creation of Duncan Reviews. 

9125926.webp

Profile image for Duncan Reviews

Image Courtesy of Rate Your Music

Nick: Hey Duncan, how’ve you been?

 

Duncan: I’m good! It’s finally beginning to feel like spring where I live, so I can do away with the heavy sweaters and the depressing music (or at least some of it). As much as I romanticize the wintertime, I always feel much better when it’s warmer.

 

Nick: A good place to start isn’t even music related. I saw recently that you reviewed the entire Diary of a Wimpy Kid series. As some who stopped reading that series at “Old School” when I entered high school, in what ways, both stylistically and narratively, has the series progressed in recent years? Do you see it as a positive or negative?

 

Duncan: I believe I also originally dropped off around “Old School” for the same reasons, but having caught up with the series after graduating and reading every new book upon release ever since, I have to say that Diary of a Wimpy Kid is in a very iffy place right now in terms of quality. I suspect this may be owed to a change in Jeff Kinney’s life and inspirations-the way he writes Greg Heffley simply no longer reflects the thoughts or actions of a middle schooler. The books themselves often rely on side characters or vacation plots and while there are still highs and lows. I’m sorry to say that the series might not find its spirit again.

 

Nick: As a young adult, what are some things about Greg that you’ve picked up on in regards to his character and decision making? Is it true that he’s worse in the books than he is played by Zachary Gordon in the film adaptation?

 

Duncan: It’s true that book Greg and movie Greg are very different people. Some of this can be boiled down to the fact that the former is actively writing down his every notion while the latter is portrayed in the moment. Both make mistakes, both have very perplexing personality traits at times, but it’s easier to find the darker, stranger aspects of a person when flipping through their top-secret diary. Props to Zachary Gordon for making the character his own with those performances!

 

Nick: What’s your favorite installment of the Wimpy Kid series?

 

Duncan: “Cabin Fever” for sure. The storytelling gives readers a perfect split between Greg’s home life and his time at school, something that has seen a huge imbalance in recent books. Most of the “classic” books feel very nostalgic to me, especially now when they are all fresh in my mind, but “Cabin Fever” just immediately feels like the peak Diary of a Wimpy Kid.

81VdTibfLCL._SL1491_.jpg

Jeff KInney - "Diary of a Wimpy Kid: Old School" (2015) book cover

Image Courtesy of Amazon

9163NWq2PxL._SL1500_.jpg

Nick: Transitioning to current music, I think 2025 might be outpacing 2024. As of writing this, “Ghostholding” by Venturing and “Black'!Antique” by Pink Siifu have been in heavy rotation. I’m curious to know what 2025 albums that you've found yourself returning to lately?

 

Duncan: My unofficial pick for album of the year so far is “Nothing,” the latest release from Nicolás Jaar’s DARKSIDE band! Their 2013 debut “Psychic” blew my mind wide open when I was a teenager and pretty much single-handedly introduced me to Electronic music. This new one is a big change of pace, but I can’t get enough of it.

a2917921097_10.jpg

DARKSIDE - "Nothing" (2015) album cover

Image Courtesy of Bandcamp

Nick: I touched on this with K-the-I??? but do you think this year has had a better turnout with Hip Hop compared to 2024?

 

Duncan: I had a great time with Hip Hop last year, but looking back on it, not many of my favorites were released prior to where we are now in 2025. On top of some standard top-tier releases, I think that surprise drops like Kendrick’s “GNX” and the sad circumstances behind Ka’s “The Thief Next to Jesus” made those albums stand out to me. Let’s hope this year has more of the former.

12744501.jpeg

Kendrick Lamar - "GNX" (2024) album cover

Image Courtesy of Rate Your Music

12446433.jpeg

Ka - "The Thief Next To Jesus" (2024) album cover

Image Courtesy of Rate Your Music

Nick: A 2025 release I saw you review was one that I didn’t know even released until you brought it to my attention. This is from a trio that I’ve been aware of since 2019 but haven’t exactly paid much attention to, Men I Trust. What were you most excited or surprised about with their latest full-length?

 

Duncan: I saw Men I Trust in concert back in 2022 and it was enlightening to get a look into their stage dynamics and their little jams in between popular songs! I was excited to hear that their new album, the first of two on the docket for 2025, let listeners in on that action in a studio context. Their progression is very subtle, but I look forward to stronger traces of Folk and Jazz becoming one with the band’s Bedroom Pop sound from here on out.

a2645358223_10.jpg

Men I Trust - "Equus Asinus" (2025) album cover

Image Courtesy of Bandcamp

Nick: I’ve noticed that you regard many past releases of Men I Trust as “tens.” What’s the appeal of them coming from someone who only recalls their overplayed single, “Show Me How?

 

Duncan: When “Show Me How” blew up, I was internally a little frustrated that people probably wouldn’t be looking much further into the Men I Trust catalog. That song is just one of many dreamy masterpieces in “Oncle Jazz,” one of my all-time favorite albums regardless of genre and an experience that I recommend as often as possible. Both that and 2021’s “Untourable” Album are streams of consciousness that completely absorb my mind at all times. The latter has grown off of me just a little, so I might not consider it a five-star record these days, but I like to revisit my review to remind myself how the music impacted me upon release.

a3970465110_10.jpg

Men I Trust - "Oncle Jazz" (2019) album cover

Image Courtesy of Bandcamp

a3470501203_10.jpg

Men I Trust - "Untourable" (2021) album cover

Image Courtesy of Bandcamp

Nick: To wind it back, when did you first start listening to music outside of just the radio? Was this something gradual or was this always present down to your earliest memories?

 

Duncan: I was raised on some awesome music! I grew up on songs from Pavement, Pixies, Nirvana, Beastie Boys, and a hundred other great bands and singers who I have my parents to thank for passing down to me. Like any other kid, I had my phases of obsession, particularly one with Imagine Dragons (they were better back in 2015), but it wasn’t until I binged the whole Gorillaz discography that the prospect of seeking out more music for myself became prevalent. Their range really broadened my taste.

 

Nick: Why did you start reviewing music and when did this take place? Did its debut occur on Rate Your Music, Instagram or something else?

 

Duncan: I started jotting down notes about my favorite songs for my own enjoyment around late 2018, a venture that lasted well over a year despite having no public audience or long-term aim, but the idea of a higher-effort online review journal only began to take shape when the lockdowns began in 2020. Many of my earlier reviews come from drafts that I wrote while biking (yes, during the actual act of biking-there weren’t many cars on the roads, see) over that responsibility-lite extended summer break. I posted my first review on Instagram just a few weeks after I moved to England and the rest is history!

 

Nick: I have to say, not to glaze, but you're probably one of the most consistent writers on both Rate Your Music and Instagram respectively. What’s your writing background and is thisnsomething you pursued academically and if so, for what career or field of study?

 

Duncan: I don’t write professionally. I actually work as a head chef and a graphic designer!- but writing has been omnipresent in my life for as long as I can remember. As a child, I wrote a lengthy series of books that seriously ripped off Lemony Snicket’sA Series of Unfortunate Events” and later on, my creative writing assignments through middle and high school allowed me to broaden my style. Along with my reviews, I log thousands of words into various personal projects every week. Music is just one of my many inspirations!

 

Nick: What are some of those current personal projects of yours if you’re willing to share?

 

Duncan: I write and illustrate comics during my downtime, make short films with my brother, and take extensive research notes about a range of topics including Greek mythology and Arthurian legends. I blame my attention span. There are always lots of hobbies and projects keeping my brain restless and productive.

 

Nick: I also heard you mention that you’re a chef somewhere sometime ago. How did you get into the culinary arts and become a head chef? Is there a specific type of food you specialize in?

 

Duncan: My dad is a chef, so I’ve always been fascinated by food, but my personal journey started back in 2022. My brother and I worked together in a little takeout burger shop for a few months over the summer, and when I went back to England for university, I immediately started working in a pub to keep that interest going. I took over the kitchen about a year later. We specialize in pizzas and chicken dishes. It’s very fun!

 

Nick: What’s your favorite dish to cook and prepare?

 

Duncan: I have a special place in my heart for Mexican food, and I try my best to emulate those dishes at home for myself and my girlfriend. I also make up my own one-pan recipes every so often. The key to making delicious food is lots of seasoning!

 

Nick: Back to music, do you play any instruments or are you strictly a listener/writer?

 

Duncan: I played the trumpet very poorly in school and rented a saxophone for the sole purpose of playing “The Girl from Ipanema.” Since then, I have felt no urge to learn any instruments. I made a bunch of rough beats on GarageBand in 2020 but I sincerely hope to forget those soon.

 

Nick: How do you tend to first approach and structure a review?

 

Duncan: I let the music take the wheel. It all depends on how the album speaks to me, as I try my best to align the experience with an appropriate setting and mood. Some music makes me want to write a world of my own, while others demand historical context or a brief rundown on the artist’s career. I find that the level of experimentation in an album impacts my style of writing- I wouldn’t throw a string of glitchy text effects into a Led Zeppelin review, but anything goes for a sonic oddity like Qebrμs!

 

Nick: I’m amazed that you’ve managed to pump out three quality reviews per day for years now. How do you find the time outside of life to sit down and write them?

 

Duncan: Funnily enough, I rarely sit down at all when I’m writing! I walk for at least a few hours a day and I find that my mind becomes more creative when the rest of my body is active. If you ever see a dude similar to my profile picture wearing earbuds and typing furiously on his phone, it just might be me.

 

Nick: I also have noticed that there are certain reviews that diverge from this format, taking more creative liberties. I’d like to discuss some of these starting with the 2006 Hypnagogic masterpiece, “1992 Cool Runnings” by Lamborghini Crystal. How do you think the stylistic typography in a sectioned format helped elevate that specific review?

 

Duncan: For context, Lamborghini Crystal is one of James Ferraro’s countless incarnations. Most of my Ferraro reviews have very little to do with the music in a technical or literal way, and instead focus on whatever world his sounds construct in my mind’s eye. This is the case for a lot of ambient-adjacent or otherwise bizarre albums, but I can always rely on Ferraro’s murky tapes to inspire some weirdness in my own creations.

2312823.jpeg

Lamborghini Crystal - "1992 Cool Runnings" (2006) album cover

Image Courtesy of Rate Your Music

Nick: Then there’s the review you did for the 2011 Massive Attack & Burial collab, “Four Walls / Paradise Circus.” Why did you decide to replicate a numbered track format that housed the review? Did you feel like a strictly track by-track analysis was more fitting for a release like this?

 

Duncan: I was similarly inspired by “Four Walls / Paradise Circus” and each song’s eerie electronic atmosphere! I believe that, at the time of my writing the review, I was taking a stroll in the downtown foggy darkness and finding a great deal of symmetry between the music and the environment around me.

massive-attack-vs-burial-four-walls-paradise-circus-Cover-Art.webp

Massive Attack & Burial - "Four Walls / Paradise Circus" (2011) album cover

Image Courtesy of Rate Your Music

Nick: Then there’s a review you did way back in 2023 regarding the 1988 release, “Lincoln,” by They Might Be Giants. I thought it was interesting how you opened up this review by defining what you believe the group’s name stands for. I’m curious to know why you opened up the review like that?

 

Duncan: My most memorable connection with They Might Be Giants took place during my childhood, where I would listen to their educational albums, “Here Come the ABCs” and “Here Comes Science” for hours on end. Projects like “Lincoln” are obviously more mature, but I wanted to give myself an inside reference to those original personal experiences by setting up a little lesson of my own.

8050253.png

They Might Be Giants - "Lincoln" (1988) album cover

Image Courtesy of Rate Your Music

Nick: Outside of the content, I notice that on your Instagram, album art traverses through eons of color schemes and patterns. What does this do for you?

 

Duncan: From around 2022 (I think) until I began accepting commissioned reviews, whose cover art I sadly can’t predict and work into a color scheme, I fell into a habit of wanting a visual component at play as well as the written reviews. I often scroll through those grids on my own and admire my past self’s picks (not to brag). I’m a graphic designer and an avid fan of hand-drawing my own comics and stories, so the appearance of a project is always important in everything I do.

 

Nick: I saw that you also review music on Rate Your Music. Why do you prefer that platform over Album of the Year?

 

Duncan: I truthfully have never even considered using AOTY over RYM. I’ve forgotten why I chose the latter in the first place if it weren’t for a function on the site that says “when you signed up for RYM, we asked you where you heard about the site and you said: ‘Anthony Fantano.’” Many thanks to him.

 

Nick: I saw that you’ve opened up your reviews to commissions. Why did you decide to add that branch to your content?

 

Duncan: Not only was I becoming stressed at the prospect of my Instagram DMs piling up with artists looking for promotion, I genuinely wanted to listen to as many of these recommendations as possible. Commissioned reviews are a way for me to put some pressure on myself to do so on a time limit and I am very happy to say that I’ve enjoyed all the music sent my way since! I’m not surprised that my followers’ good taste in music extends to their performance thereof.

 

Nick: What were some of your biggest discoveries through these commissions?

 

Duncan: I’d like to give a shoutout to “He Called Hex” by Kit Le Bihan, one of my favorite releases of 2025 so far! Kamikaze Prom Night, Genie String Bass, Horse Saturday, and Shuffleboard Productions all come to mind as well when thinking off the top of my head about exciting indie acts with relatively recent releases. I was also thrilled to receive a commission from Haunted Disco, whose music I had already heard prior to that exciting collab!

a0256430246_10.jpg

Kit Le Bihan - "He Called Hex" (2025) album cover

Image Courtesy of Bandcamp

a0800939400_10.jpg

Haunted Disco - "IF I LIVED IN IGNORANCE" (2024) album cover

Image Courtesy of Bandcamp

Nick: The biggest overlap we have is interviewing, granted your interviews are less common, since reviews are your primary expertise. What made you want to start interviewing and is that

something you’d like to continue building on the side?

 

Duncan: I would love to continue interviewing artists! The biggest roadblock for me is the social element, as I’m somewhat introverted online despite being an outgoing person out there in the real world. My interviews with Xiu Xiu, Celer, Parannoul and DJ Rozwell all stemmed from a genuine urge to just ask a favorite artist of mine some curious questions. I am forever grateful that I have a platform where that can happen with ease. My interview with Nelson Everhart, the composer for two video games very near and dear to my heart, remains a highlight of my entire Duncan Reviews career.

 

Nick: Are there any artists that you want to interview sometime in the future? If given the chance, what inquiry would you have for them?

 

Duncan: I would love to speak to Molly Rankin or Angel Olsen one day. I have all the usual questions about writing processes and inspirations, but I also like to ask about the basics- favorite colors, TV shows, and so on. It’s nice to get a glimpse at the person behind the art, not just the artist.

 

Nick: I also notice that many of your interviews pull from irony. Was this a way to creatively express your praise or criticism to certain artists like MC Ride and Meghan Trainor through comedy?

 

Duncan: I adore those two posts and while the Meghan Trainor “interview” was an April Fool’s celebration I had been plotting for weeks on end, I cannot for the life of me remember what drove me to make a screenplay-style dream (or possibly nightmare) scenario involving an interrogation between MC Ride and I. The future may hold one or two more of those pranks, only time will tell. There’s also some deep lore about an interview that very much failed. We’ll see if I ever reveal what happened there.

 

Nick: To top this off, I saw that you're not far from reaching 5000 reviews which is absolutely insane. Do you have any plans of celebrating this milestone in some way? Would it be similar to the three year milestone post you made in late 2023?

 

Duncan: I believe it was a 1000-post celebration several years ago that saw the release of my top 1000 albums of all time, and while it would definitely be achievable to do the same for the 5000 or so I’m at these days, I don’t think I have it in me to ask questions like “were The Rolling Stones better at making Rock music than Merzbow is at making noise music?” (though, thinking about it, I’d say my answer there would be “no”). With that said, I’ll be hitting my five-year anniversary of Duncan Reviews this October and I’m already sorting through potential plans for that happy day!

 

Nick: Thanks for letting me interview you Duncan. Anything you’d like to leave us on?

 

Duncan: Thank you for keeping up with my work! I do this out of a compulsion to cover my thoughts on everything I’ve ever listened to, and it’s been amazing to see a community blossom out of that hobby. Boy, do I love music.

©2023 - 2025 by Nick Caceres. Powered by Wix

bottom of page